How to Tell if a Publisher is Predatory

Predatory publishers prey on inexperienced authors, offering services that seem appealing at first but ultimately leave authors with little to show for their efforts. Understanding how to identify these unscrupulous companies is critical for protecting your work and your wallet.

One of the clearest signs of a predatory publisher is the request for upfront fees. Legitimate publishers make their money through book sales, not by charging authors for publication. If a publisher asks you for significant upfront payment for services like editing, marketing, or distribution, you should be cautious. While some publishers may charge for certain services, a reputable company typically does so in exchange for a reasonable share of royalties, not a flat fee.

Another warning sign is vague or non-existent contracts. Predatory publishers may offer authors very limited or confusing contracts that give them control over your intellectual property or provide little detail about your rights and royalties. Always ensure that your contract is clear, and never sign something that you don’t fully understand. It’s wise to consult a lawyer or agent to review any contract before signing.

Many predatory publishers also engage in false promises. They may claim to guarantee book sales, top-tier distribution, or instant success—all things that are not guaranteed in the competitive publishing industry. Beware of publishers that make unrealistic promises without a proven track record of success.

In some cases, predatory publishers will not offer editing or marketing services, leaving the burden of these tasks entirely on the author. Instead of helping you improve and promote your book, they simply print it and expect you to handle everything else. This lack of support indicates that the publisher is more interested in taking your money than helping you succeed.

Finally, look at the company’s track record. If a publisher has a history of authors complaining about not receiving royalties, poor sales, or not getting proper distribution, it’s a huge red flag. Check online reviews, writing forums, and social media for feedback from other authors who’ve worked with the publisher.

Protecting yourself from predatory publishers requires research and vigilance. Always take the time to investigate any company you're considering working with and trust your instincts. If something feels off, it probably is.

Comments